International Council for the Exploration of the Sea
WKAREA3 Report 2019.pdf (1.77 MB)

Third Workshop on Age Reading of European and American Eel (WKAREA3)

Download (1.77 MB)
posted on 2020-01-01, 00:00 authored by ICESICES
The Working Group on Age Reading of European and American Eel (WKAREA) seeks to im-prove the accuracy and precision of age estimates across the range of the species based on stand-ardized methods and criteria, in order to support stock assessment at local and global levels. The group conducted a collective reading of European eel otoliths extracted from eels sampled in six aquatic systems from the South West Europe area (SUDOE area), which had been poorly repre-sented in previous workshops. In this report the group analyses the results of the intercalibration process, identifies causes of error and their consequences on precision and accuracy, and pro-vides recommendations for future work. The aging performance of advanced and basic readers was poor, suggesting that the growth patterns rather than the reader experience are responsible for the low consistency among readers. The otoliths from the southern part of the eel range pre-sented an overall growth pattern, that is completely different from what has been seen in otoliths from the northern area. The irregular pattern of annuli along with the presence of numerous supernumerary rings complicated the interpretation of the growth pattern in the otoliths used in the exchange. It was concluded that it was impossible to distinguish between annuli and super-numerary rings. In habitats from the south, especially the Mediterranean region it is likely that low river flow during summer, associated with high temperatures, are responsible for the depo-sition of many supernumerary rings. In view of the uncertainty associated with the age estima-tion of eels in the southern area, there are concerns in the use of age readings data for stock assessment. To further increase precision and reduce the risk of biased growth estimates in the southern area, it is a priority that mark recapture studies are conducted to ground truth the age and identify patterns of ring formation. A field study to test the effect of summer temperature and river flow on eel growth patterns in the southern area should clarify the patterns of annuli formation.


Published under the auspices of the following ICES Steering Group or Committee

  • EOSG

Published under the auspices of the following ICES Expert Group or Strategic Initiative



ICES Scientific Reports





Contributors (Editors)

Isabel Domingos; Françoise Daverat; Kélig Mahé

Contributors (Authors)

Carmen Abaroa; Elsa Amilhat; Carlos Antunes; Hakan Ayyildiz; Agnès Bardonnet; Cédric Briand Celina Chantre; José Lino Costa; Anna Costarrosa; Françoise Daverat; Isabel Domingos; Estibaliz Díaz; Caroline Durif; Derek Evans; Carlos Fernández Delgado; Marko Freese; Christine Gazeau Lukasz lgiedrojc; Marju Kaljuste; Arantza Maceira; Rui Monteiro; Ana Moura; Tomasz Nermer Voula Papadopoulou; Russell Poole; Jacques Rives; Ramón Miguel Rubio; Argyrios Sapounidis Brice Sauvaget; Jennie Strömquist; Sami Vesala; Lluís Zamora



Recommended citation

ICES. 2020. Third Workshop on Age Reading of European and American Eel (WKAREA3) ICES Scientific Reports. 2:84. 34 pp.

Usage metrics

    ICES Scientific Reports


    Ref. manager