International Council for the Exploration of the Sea
WGFBIT2022 final.pdf (6.87 MB)
Download file

Working Group on Fisheries Benthic Impact and Trade-offs (WGFBIT)

Download (6.87 MB)
posted on 2023-02-20, 09:53 authored by ICESICES


The Working Group on Fisheries Benthic Impact and Trade-offs (WGFBIT) develops methods and performs assessments to evaluate benthic impact from fisheries at regional scale, while considering fisheries and seabed impact trade-offs. 

In this report, new fishery benthic impact assessments (ToR A) are shown out for several sub-regions in (French Mediterranean, Celtic Seas). For other regions, updates of the whole assessment or specific steps only were presented.

To further standardise the different components of the WGFBIT approach across all (sub-)regional assessments, a more detail overview of those components was compiled. These components were slightly different among those regions, related to variation in data availability, environmental characteristics and implementation possibilities among the (sub-)regions. 

In WGFBIT, assessments are sometimes based on trawl or grab data, which are sampling different components of the seafloor ecosystem and can have consequences on the created sensitivity layer. Therefore, there is looked in more detail how the sensitivity outcome (and layers) can differ due to the use of benthic data gathered with different gears (grab/core, trawl or video). The preliminary comparability analyses are performed on different levels: (1) based on co-located sampling; (2) comparing sensitivity maps of the (sub-) area, based on different gears. There were differences observed in longevity distribution at locations sampled with different gears and differences in data and models lead also to differences in the sensitivity layers. 

The WGFBIT seafloor assessment framework is not the only way to assess benthic impacts from physical disturbance. A discussion session was held on how the future workflow on advice that ICES WGFBIT assessment contribute to, will be organized.

Marine sediments harbour significant levels of biodiversity that play a key role in ecosystem functions and services such as biogeochemical cycling, carbon storage and the regulation of climate. Through the removal of fauna, changes in physico-chemical nature and resuspension of sediment, bottom trawling may result in significant changes in the ecosystem functioning of shelf seas. An assumption of the current PD model is that high community biomass implies higher ecosystem functioning. However, total community biomass does not necessarily reflect changes in species and functional trait composition which play a key role in regulating ecosystem functions. ToR D is working on an improved understanding of the link between species functional effect traits and proxies and processes for specific ecosystem functions to improve our ability to predict the impact of fishing disturbance on benthic ecosystem functioning more accurately. Links between species traits and biogeochemical parameters and the impact of trawling on these links are being explored using multivariate ordination analyses using different fauna and biogeochemical datasets collected in the North Sea, Celtic Sea, Kattegat, Baltic Sea and the eastern Mediterranean. Changes due to trawling in the trajectories of species densities over time and the concurrent changes in the bioturbation and bioirrigation potential of communities are being modelled using a combination of data-driven mechanistic model and a biogeochemical model. We report on the different data analysis methods that ToR D members have developed over the last year.


Published under the auspices of the following ICES Steering Group or Committee


Published under the auspices of the following ICES Expert Group or Strategic Initiative



ICES Scientific Reports





Contributors (Editors)

Jan Geert Hiddink • Gert van Hoey • Marija Sciberras

Contributors (Authors)

Andrea Pierucci • Alessandra Nguyen Xuan • Bianca Di Lorenzo • Clare Bradshaw • Clement Garcia • Cristina Mangano • Cristina Vina-Herbon • Chris Smith • Daan Cuyvers • Daniel van Denderen • David Clare • Elisa Punzo • Gabriele Di Bona • Gert Van Hoey • Giada Rava • Irini Tsikopoulou • Jan Geert Hiddink • Jochen Depestele • Joanna Desmidt • Jolien Claes • Justin Tiano • Karline Soetaert • Kate Morris • Lene Buhl-Mortensen • Luisa Nicoletti • Lucas Porz • Luke Batts • Mairi Fenton • Mattias Sköld • Marina Penna • Marina Pulcini • Marta Mega Rufino • Marija Sciber-ras • Mats Blomqvist • Nadia Papadopoulou • Neve McCann • Olivier Beauchard • Pascal Laffargue • Paul Coleman • Ruth Parker • Sandrine Vaz • Sebastian Valanko • Sebastiaan Vandevelde • Stefan Bolam • Tobias Van Kooten • Wenyan Zhang



Recommended citation

ICES. 2023. Working Group on Fisheries Benthic Impact and Trade-offs (WGFBIT; outputs from 2022 meeting). ICES Scientific Reports. 5:16. 106 pp.