IWKNSMSE 2019_Full report.pdf (45.84 MB)
Download file

Workshop on North Sea Stocks Management Strategy Evaluation (WKNSMSE)

Download (45.84 MB)
posted on 2019-01-01, 00:00 authored by ICESICES

WKNSMSE (Workshop on North Sea stocks Management Strategy Evaluation) took place over two physical meetings (19-21 November 2018 and 26-28 February 2019, but at ICES HQ, Copenhagen) and several WebEx meetings, was chaired by José De Oliveira (UK) and included 30 par-ticipants from Denmark, Germany, Netherlands, Norway, Sweden, UK and the European Commission, and two reviewers from South African and New Zealand. The purpose of this work was to evaluate long-term management strategies for jointly-managed stocks in the North Sea (cod, haddock, whiting, saithe and autumn-spawning herring) between the European Union and Norway, following a request from EU-Norway. The first physical meeting provided an ICES interpretation of the EU-Norway request, agreed the specifications of the MSE, decided on the tools and approaches to use, and developed a work plan, while the second meeting (and subsequent follow-up WebEx meetings) discussed results, developed conclusions, ensured the minimum requirements for conducting MSEs (developed by WKGMSE2) were met, and finalised the report. ICES were tasked to find “optimal” combinations of harvest control rule parameters (Ftarget and Btrigger) for management strategies with or without stability mechanisms (TAC constraints and banking and borrowing scenarios). “Optimal” combinations were defined as those combinations of Ftarget and Btrigger that simultaneously maximised long-term yield while being precautionary (long-term risk3≤5%). The request also asked for sensitivity tests once the management strategies were “optimised”. The approach adopted for all stocks was to include the assessment and fore-cast in a full-feedback MSE simulation, and to condition the baseline operating model on the benchmarked ICES assessment. The one exception was haddock, where it was not possible to include TSA in the full-feedback simulation because it was too slow to converge and requires manual intervention; SAM was used instead as a reasonable approximation. The approach also considered alternative operating models to capture a broader range of uncertainties. Full-feed-back simulations were computationally challenging and required the use of parallelisation and high-performance computing; it also meant that the time-frame for the work was extremely tight, and in some cases, analyses were restricted. Nonetheless, the work was completed for all stocks, and “optimal” combinations for most management strategies were found. There were some no-table issues that arose through this suite of MSEs, including that some management strategies that were precautionary in the long-term could have unsavoury and avoidable features in the short term (depending on the management strategy), and that reference points estimated by EqSim were, in many cases, no longer found to be precautionary in the MSE.


Published under the auspices of the following ICES Steering Group or Committee

  • FRSG

Published under the auspices of the following ICES Expert Group or Strategic Initiative



ICES Scientific Reports





Contributors (Editors)

José A. A. De Oliveira

Contributors (Authors)

Valerio Bartolino; Benoit Berges; Mollie E. Brooks; Massimiliano Cardinale; Harriet S. Cole; José A. A. De Oliveira; Jennifer A. Devine; Gjert E. Dingsør; Simon H. Fischer; Daisuke Goto; Niels T. Hintzen; Daniel Howell; Ernesto Jardim; Alexander Kempf; Cecilie Kvamme; Steve Mackinson; Alessandro Mannini; Tanja Miethe; Henrik Mosegaard; Iago Mosqueira; Anders Nielsen; Martin Pastoors; Cecilia Pinto; Norbert Rohlf; Claus R. Sparrevohn; Marc Taylor; Vanessa Trijoulet; Ibrahim Umar; Nicola D. Walker



Recommended citation

ICES. 2019. Workshop on North Sea stocks management strategies evaluation (WKNSMSE). ICES Scientific Reports. 1:12. 378 pp. http://doi.org/10.17895/ices.pub.5090