International Council for the Exploration of the Sea
WKVALPEL Report 2019.pdf (2.73 MB)

Workshop on age validation studies of small pelagic species (WKVALPEL)

Download (2.73 MB)
posted on 2019-01-01, 00:00 authored by ICESICES

The Workshop on age validation studies of small pelagic species (WKVALPEL) focused on validating ageing criteria for small pelagic species (anchovy, horse mackerel, chub mackerel, mackerel and sardine). The aim of the workshop was to collate information on existing ageing protocols and to use these to support development of a validated protocol to better standardize age estimates.  
One of the main sources of error affecting ageing precision is the discrimination between the false ring and annulus. An ageing process follows a number of typical steps. First, an ageing methodology is established, based on scientific information, to obtain age data for a particular species. Once age results are available, some analysis is recommended to improve precision among different readers and/or readings. The next step is to perform other studies that offer independent results used to support, or not, an accepted ageing methodology. Several matching and independent results help to corroborate certain ageing criteria. Each study determines how precision and/or trueness are enhanced. In general, these methods are included in indirect or semi-direct validation categories, as true ages are not actually known in any of them. Some other methodologies, usually more complex and costly, are considered strictly as validation experiments, as results approach to real ages. Tagging-recapture experiments and rearing in captivity are included within this category.  
The latest available information on ageing data (precision and/or validation studies) was pre-sented for a number of different species of small pelagics. Methods highlighted included mar-ginal increment analysis (MIA), marginal analysis (MA), length frequency distribution analysis (LFDA) and back calculation (BC). A synthesis table of the last annual growth workshops and exchanges by species is also presented. The goal, for each species (Engraulis encrasiculus, Sardina pilchardus, Clupea harengus, Sprattus sprattus, Scomber scombrus, Scomber colias, Trachurus trachurus, Trachurus mediterraneus, Trachurus picturatus, Micromesistius potassou), was to add information on the exchange or workshop and to present the major difficulties that caused low Percentage of Agreement between the age readers as well as to recommend some guidelines to overcome those difficulties.
Given that several methods exist for validation of age readings of calcified structures, a summary table of age validation methods used for all small and medium pelagic species in European waters was developed with a focus on the feasibility for the small pelagic species and validation strength of the folowing methods: BC, LFDA, Weight frequency distribution (WFD), Progression of strong year-classes, MIA, MA, daily growth increments (DGI), Daily increments widths, Tag-recapture analysis and Captive rearing. 


Published under the auspices of the following ICES Steering Group or Committee

  • EOSG

Published under the auspices of the following ICES Expert Group or Strategic Initiative



ICES Scientific Reports





Contributors (Editors)

Pierluigi Carbonara; Kélig Mahé; Javier Rey

Contributors (Authors)

Andrea Bellodi; Geoffrey Bled Defruit; Pierluigi Carbonara; Louise Cox; Celina Chantre; Julie Davies Adel Gaamour; Carmen Gloria Piñeiro; Patricia Goncalves; Julita Gutkowska; Annelie Hilvarsson; Andrea Massaro; Konstantina Ofridopoulou; Vaso Papantoniou; Andreia Silva; Begona Villamor



Recommended citation

ICES. 2020.Workshop on age validation studies of small pelagic species (WKVALPEL). ICES Scientific Reports. 2:15. 76 pp.

Usage metrics

    ICES Scientific Reports


    Ref. manager